In Zaragoza they call it the third cathedral, and that is not an affectionate exaggeration: for size, for quality and for what it holds inside, this church in the El Gancho quarter stands level with the Pilar and the Seo. Its octagonal Mudéjar tower, of brick, is listed as World Heritage, and inside there is a high altarpiece that is among the finest of the Spanish Renaissance.
A minaret tower in a working quarter
The tower is fourteenth century, octagonal, of brick, with geometric decoration laid proud covering the whole shaft and an inner structure of two concentric shells with the stair running between them. That scheme — a tower within a tower — comes straight from Almohad minarets.
It is one of the peaks of Aragonese Mudéjar, listed collectively as World Heritage, and what is remarkable is where it stands: not in a church of royal or noble patronage but in the church of a craftsmen's suburb, outside the Roman wall.
That means it was raised by a parish without great revenues, with the cheapest material available and with local labour of Andalusi tradition. Aragonese Mudéjar is, to a large extent, architecture of exceptional quality made on a modest budget.
Damián Forment's altarpiece
The high altarpiece is the work of Damián Forment, the most important sculptor of the Aragonese Renaissance, carved in polychrome wood in the first decades of the sixteenth century. It fills the whole east end with scenes from the life of the Virgin and of Saint Paul, arranged in bays and tiers.
Forment also worked on the high altarpiece of the Pilar and on that of Huesca cathedral, and his style combines the Gothic structure of bays and canopies with figures that are already fully Renaissance, Italian in anatomy and movement. Seeing that crossing in a single piece is what makes it interesting.
The rest of the interior keeps Flemish tapestries, side chapels from various periods and a Mudéjar timber ceiling in some bays. It is a far richer church than its setting in a working-class quarter would lead you to expect.
Highlights
The third cathedral
For size and quality it stands level with the Pilar and the Seo, despite being the church of a craftsmen's suburb.
A tower within a tower
Two concentric octagonal shells with the stair between them, a scheme inherited from Almohad minarets.
Forment's altarpiece
Gothic structure of bays and canopies with figures already Renaissance. The two languages crossing in a single piece.
Quality on a modest budget
Raised by a parish without great revenues, with brick and local labour of Andalusi tradition.
How it fits into your visit to Zaragoza
It stands in the El Gancho quarter, west of the old town, ten minutes from the Plaza del Pilar and close to the Mercado Central. It is a working-class quarter, very mixed, with very little tourist presence.
Visiting hours are restricted and tied to worship, so it is worth checking before you go: it is easily found closed. The tower can be seen from the street at any hour and is worth walking round.
Together with the church of la Magdalena, at the opposite end of the old town, it makes up the pair of Mudéjar towers to see in this city. Only San Pablo's is listed as World Heritage, and both go largely unnoticed.
Frequently asked questions
Who was that Damián Forment of the altarpiece?
The great name in sculpture of his time in these parts. Damián Forment, of Valencian origin, triumphed in the Aragon of the early sixteenth century and left altarpieces that are genuine mountains of carved figures. If this one impresses you, bear in mind that the great alabaster altarpieces of the Pilar basilica, right next door, and of Huesca cathedral are his too, as well as his work at the monastery of Poblet. An artist who carved alabaster and wood as if they were wax. Having him in this neighbourhood is an enormous luxury.
Since when has it been a World Heritage Site?
For a few decades now, and it does not stand alone. UNESCO declared Aragonese Mudéjar a World Heritage Site in 1986, starting with the monuments of Teruel, and in 2001 it widened the list to include Zaragoza: this tower of San Pablo, the lantern and the Parroquieta of the Seo that you saw at the start, and the Aljafería palace. So it is not an isolated jewel, but part of a treasure spread all over Aragon and recognised by the whole world. And you have it, would you believe, in the humblest neighbourhood.
How could a humble neighbourhood raise such a tower?
That is the charm of the story. This suburb, outside the walls, filled up with craftsmen and a powerful market, and all those working people, grouped in their guilds, were far more prosperous than they looked. The parish grew with them and, century after century, poured that money into its church: the tower, the altarpiece, the tapestries. That is why the poor neighbourhood ended up with a 'cathedral' the centre would envy. No king or bishop paid for it: a whole neighbourhood of busy hands paid for it, a pinch at a time.
