Its tower leans. It is of brick, octagonal, Mudéjar, and it tilts quite visibly when seen from the Plaza del Pilar, at whose western end the church stands. The lean is neither an optical effect nor a builder's whim: it is a consequence of the ground, and it has been there for centuries without the building coming down.
A leaning tower of brick
The tilt is down to the subsoil: the tower was raised close to the old course of the Ebro, on soft and uneven alluvial ground, and the differential settlement of the foundations gradually leaned it over. It is the same mechanism that produced the famous case of Pisa, on another scale.
The tower is Mudéjar, from the sixteenth century, octagonal in plan and decorated with brick laid proud, though more sober than those of the Magdalena or San Pablo. It was kept when the church was rebuilt in Baroque, so the whole combines two clearly different periods.
It is worth looking at from several points around the square, because the perception of the tilt changes a great deal with the angle: from some points you barely notice it, and from others it is obvious and even unsettling. The best point is from the side of the Torreón de la Zuda.
A military order from the Holy Land
The full name, San Juan de los Panetes, mixes two things. San Juan refers to the Order of the Hospital of Saint John of Jerusalem, the Hospitallers, one of the great military orders born of the crusades, which held a commandery here.
The Hospitallers received enormous properties in Aragon after the conquest of Zaragoza in 1118, partly through the famous will of Alfonso I the Battler, who left his kingdom to the military orders of the Holy Land. That will was never carried out, but it left the orders with a considerable estate in the Ebro valley.
And the Panetes part is explained far more domestically: it comes from the little bread rolls handed out here to the poor, in the charitable tradition tied to the order. A place name that crosses the crusades with the alms of bread.
Highlights
The tower leans
From differential settlement of the foundations on alluvial ground, near the old course of the Ebro.
It changes with the angle
From some points on the square you barely notice it and from others it is obvious. The best point is the Zuda side.
It belonged to the Hospitallers
The military order born of the crusades, which received enormous properties in Aragon after the conquest of 1118.
Panetes comes from bread rolls
The ones handed out here to the poor. A place name that crosses the crusades with the alms of bread.
How it fits into your visit to Zaragoza
It stands at the western end of the Plaza del Pilar, beside the Torreón de la Zuda and the Roman walls. It is the way into the square if you come from the Mercado Central.
The interior keeps very restricted hours tied to worship and is easily found closed. The tower, which is the thing to see, can be taken in from the square at any hour and without going in.
It is a five-minute stop and fits naturally with the free viewpoint of the Zuda, a minute away, from which, incidentally, the tilt of the tower can be seen from above quite clearly.
Frequently asked questions
What was an order from the Holy Land doing here?
It is a most curious inheritance. When Alfonso I the Battler died without children, in his will he left nothing less than his entire kingdom to the three great military orders of the Holy Land: the Templars, the Hospitallers and the Holy Sepulchre. His nobles refused to carry out such a folly, but the orders ended up receiving lands, houses and churches all over Aragon, and this was one of them.
