From outside it is a discreet church, hidden among narrow lanes, with no monumental front and no square before it. Inside it has two thousand square metres of vaulting covered in frescoes, from floor to ceiling, in a burst of clouds, colour and figures. They call it the Valencian Sistine Chapel and the comparison, for once, is not overblown. It was blackened by smoke for centuries and a restoration completed in 2016 gave it back whole.
Gothic underneath, Baroque on top
The parish of San Nicolás de Bari and San Pedro Mártir is one of the oldest in Valencia: there are documents from the thirteenth century and its present structure is Gothic, of the fourteenth, with a single nave, chapels between the buttresses and pointed arches. That architecture is still there, underneath everything.
At the end of the seventeenth century it was decided to cover it. Antonio Palomino, painter to the king and the great theorist of the Spanish Baroque, designed the complete programme, and Dionís Vidal carried it out in fresco between 1697 and 1700. The result is not a decoration over the Gothic: it is a complete wrapping that hides it.
The programme tells the lives of the two patron saints in linked scenes, with feigned architecture, perspectives that open the ceiling and a quantity of figures that is hard to take in. It is painting meant to produce astonishment in whoever walks in, exactly as the Counter-Reformation intended.
The restoration that gave the colour back
For three centuries, candle smoke, pollution and damp covered the frescoes with a dark layer that came to make them almost illegible. Anyone walking into San Nicolás in the nineteen nineties saw a brown ceiling with blurred shapes.
The restoration was carried out in phases between 2013 and 2016, funded by the Hortensia Herrero Foundation, and the result was a spectacular recovery of colour. Comparing the photographs from before and after is, on its own, a lesson in what dirt can hide.
A fact they like to tell in this church: San Nicolás de Bari, its patron, is the fourth-century bishop who left gifts and coins in secret in the houses of girls with no dowry. From that custom, by way of Holland and the United States, came the figure of Santa Claus. The modern Father Christmas has his origin in the saint to whom this ceiling is dedicated.
Highlights
Two thousand metres of fresco
The whole vault covered by Dionís Vidal between 1697 and 1700, to a design by Antonio Palomino.
Gothic hidden underneath
The fourteenth-century structure is still there: the Baroque did not decorate it, it wrapped it completely.
The restoration of 2016
Three centuries of smoke had made it illegible. The before and after are two different buildings.
The saint who became Father Christmas
San Nicolás de Bari left gifts in secret. From there comes Santa Claus, by way of Holland.
How it fits into your visit to Valencia
It stands on Calle Caballeros, the main axis of the old town, five minutes from the Lonja and the Mercado Central and six from the Cathedral. It is easy to walk past without seeing it: the door is small and gives onto a side lane.
The ticket includes an explanatory projection cast onto the vaults themselves, with a lighting system that picks out one scene after another. It works well and lasts a little over twenty minutes, though it is worth knowing that you cannot walk about freely while it is running.
If you are going to see several Baroque interiors in Valencia, the order that pays off best is this: first Los Santos Juanes, also with frescoes by Palomino and badly hurt by two fires, and then San Nicolás, restored and intact. The comparison between the two explains a great deal about the recent history of the city.
Frequently asked questions
Who was this Palomino who designed the frescoes?
Antonio Palomino was one of the great painters of Spanish Baroque, court painter to the king, but he went down in history above all for his pen: he wrote a monumental work on the lives of Spanish painters, and that is why he is called «the Spanish Vasari». Thanks to that book we know today who very many artists of the Golden Age were and how they worked. Curious that this explosion of colour above you was devised, above all, by a man of biographies and letters.
Does this Saint Nicholas have anything to do with Father Christmas?
Well, yes, and it is one of my favourite facts. The church is dedicated to Saint Nicholas of Bari, a bishop who lived in the fourth century in present-day Turkey and who had a reputation for secretly leaving gifts and coins for children and the poorest. From that fame as a secret giver was born, over the centuries and many twists through the north of Europe, the character of Santa Claus, our Father Christmas. So this hidden church in El Carmen is consecrated, no more and no less, to the jolly grandfather who hands out presents at Christmas today.
