One of the most astonishing façades in the whole of Spain: a wall of stone that looks embroidered, a carved lace where not a single smooth patch is left. It is the doorway of the Colegio de San Gregorio, a masterpiece of Isabelline Gothic, and today it houses the Museo Nacional de Escultura, the national sculpture museum.
A lace of stone with no certain author
It was commissioned between 1487 and 1496 by Fray Alonso de Burgos, confessor to Isabella the Catholic, to found a college of Dominican theologians and, along the way, to leave a monument to the glory of the Catholic Monarchs.
Look from the street at the carved tree and at the wild men flanking it: hairy figures armed with clubs, a strange and fascinating medieval iconography that represented the wild and the untamed in the courtly imagination of the time.
And here is the mystery: we do not know for certain who designed it. There is no signed paper. The experts dispute it: many point to Gil de Siloé, the genius who carved the alabaster tombs of the Cartuja de Miraflores in Burgos; others speak of Simón de Colonia.
Isabelline or Hispano-Flemish Gothic is exactly this: extreme decorative density, heraldry everywhere and a carving technique verging on the impossible. It was the official style of the reign of the Catholic Monarchs.
The Museo Nacional de Escultura
Inside it is as dazzling as the doorway: the Patio de los Estudios, the great courtyard, the chapel and the staircase with its coffered ceiling. And then, the collection.
There are the San Benito altarpiece by Alonso Berruguete, the harrowing Entombment by Juan de Juni and the recumbent Christ by Gregorio Fernández. They are the three summits of Spanish sculpture in polychrome wood.
That the national sculpture museum should be here and not in Madrid has an explanation: in the Golden Age this city was the capital of polychrome wood sculpture, with the great masters working in their Valladolid workshops.
And something enormous happened in this building: between 1550 and 1551 the Valladolid Debate was held here. On one side, Fray Bartolomé de las Casas, arguing that the indigenous peoples of America were free men with rights; on the other, Ginés de Sepúlveda. It was one of the first debates in history on human rights.
Highlights
A wall that looks embroidered
Isabelline Gothic of 1487-1496, raised by the confessor of Isabella the Catholic.
Nobody knows who designed it
There is no signed paper. Gil de Siloé and Simón de Colonia are the names put forward.
It is the Museo Nacional de Escultura
With Berruguete, Juan de Juni and Gregorio Fernández: the three summits of Spanish carving.
America was debated here
The Valladolid Debate, 1550-1551, between Bartolomé de las Casas and Ginés de Sepúlveda.
How it fits into your visit to Valladolid
It stands in the quarter of the palaces, beside the church of San Pablo and the plaza de San Pablo, ten minutes from the Plaza Mayor.
The visit takes a good two hours. There is a paid ticket at a modest price and there are days with free access: check the opening hours.
The museum also extends to the Palacio de Villena, with the Neapolitan Nativity scene, and to the Casa del Sol, with the collection of plaster casts.
Frequently asked questions
Is it true that the Indians of America were debated here?
True, and it was one of the most important debates in history. Between fifteen fifty and fifteen fifty-one the so-called Valladolid Controversy met here. On one side, Fray Bartolomé de las Casas, who defended tooth and nail that the indigenous peoples of America were free men, with souls and rights; on the other, Ginés de Sepúlveda, who justified the conquest. It was one of the first times that an empire stopped to discuss whether it had the right to what it was doing.
Who designed this madness of a façade?
Well, although it may surprise you, we do not know for certain, and that is part of its mystery. There is no signed paper to clear it up. The experts argue over it: many point to Gil de Siloé, the genius who carved the alabaster tombs of the Charterhouse of Miraflores, in Burgos; others speak of Simón de Colonia or Juan Guas. A marvel like this, and we cannot even put a sure name to the artist. I leave it to your imagination.
Why is the great sculpture museum here and not in Madrid?
Because Valladolid has earned it the hard way. In the Golden Age this city was the capital of polychrome wooden sculpture: the great masters of that art had their workshops here, and here they created their most overwhelming works. Gathering the national sculpture collection right in the city where that way of carving was born made all the sense in the world. And what better setting than this one, don't you think?
